Why Fee-Free Credit Cards Stay in My Wallet Longer Than Premium Ones

Jessica is a longtime points-and-miles enthusiast and the former Personal Finance Managing Editor at U.S. News and World Report, with a focus on helping consumers make travel more affordable.

Michael Y. Park is a New York City journalist who has traveled widely, including through Afghanistan disguised as a Hazara Shi’ite, and has also spent time living the digital-nomad life since 2016 while working in social media marketing and blogging for travel brands.

We may receive compensation when you click on a link, get an application approved, or open an account with one of our advertising partners. Terms apply to the offers below. See our Advertising Policy for more on our partners, how we earn money, and how we evaluate offers. Opinions and recommendations are our own.

I get the most value from my travel rewards cards, but the no-annual-fee cards in my wallet outnumber the premium ones. Some of my oldest cards don’t offer rewards or standout perks, yet I have no plans to close them. By contrast, I’ve shut down or downgraded several premium cards once they stopped delivering enough value.

Over the years, I’ve collected nearly 20 no-annual-fee cards, and most of them have stayed open because each still serves a role, even if I rarely use some of them.

Fee-Free Cards Don’t Have to Earn Their Place

My premium cards may offer the flashiest benefits, but my no-annual-fee cards cost me nothing to keep year after year.

When I evaluate annual-fee cards, I weigh the value of the rewards and benefits I actually use each year. Fee-free cards don’t require that calculation, so I don’t feel pressure to maximize every perk, redeem every reward, or justify keeping the card for another year.

Some cards continue to matter long after I open them, such as no-annual-fee cards that earn bonus rewards on purchases I make regularly. I keep others open simply because there’s no reason to close them. As long as I monitor the account and occasionally make a purchase to avoid inactivity closure, keeping the card costs me nothing.

One example is my oldest card, a Capital One Platinum Credit Card. I first opened it as a Capital One Platinum Secured Credit Card to build credit, and later it was upgraded to an unsecured card.

That card doesn’t earn rewards or provide benefits, and I don’t use it often for spending. Still, it remains useful because of its age and credit limit, both of which help my credit score. Keeping the account open extends my credit history, since it can continue aging instead of eventually falling off my report. It also helps the average age of my accounts, while the available credit can lower my credit utilization ratio.

Bottom Line: A no-annual-fee card doesn’t need to be my best card, or even a particularly strong one, to be worth keeping.

Premium Cards Have to Justify Their Cost Every Year

I do keep a few premium cards, but I’m much faster to close one with an annual fee when it no longer works for me.

At one point, my husband and I each carried The Business Platinum Card^® from American Express. We closed both because the total fees and benefits no longer made sense, especially with overlapping perks from other premium cards we already used. I also closed my American Express^® Business Gold Card when my spending and its benefits no longer lined up well enough to justify keeping it.

My Chase Sapphire Reserve^® was harder to give up. I used it to earn rewards, and the statement credits were valuable, but they still weren’t enough compared with the other premium cards in my wallet. I eventually downgraded it to a Chase Freedom Unlimited^® so I could keep earning Chase Ultimate Rewards points without paying an annual fee.

I don’t open cards unless I see lasting value in them, but annual-fee increases and changes to benefits can quickly change a card’s worth, even if it made sense when I first applied. Changes in my travel habits, spending patterns, and overall card lineup also affect whether a premium card still deserves a place in my wallet.

Bottom Line: A card that made sense a couple of years ago may no longer be worth its annual fee.

How My Collection of Fee-Free Cards Grew

I never planned to end up with nearly 20 no-annual-fee cards, but that is how things developed over time. I started with secured cards to build credit, then opened other cards to earn specific rewards or welcome offers, access benefits, or take advantage of 0% APR promotions.

Some cards became less useful after I opened newer accounts. For instance, I downgraded my Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card to a $0-annual-fee Capital One VentureOne Rewards Credit Card, which earns 1.25 miles per $1. But after getting the Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card, which earns at least 2 miles per $1, I no longer have much reason to use the VentureOne card for purchases.

With cards that had 0% APR offers, I didn’t always have a reason to keep spending on them after I paid off the promotional balance. But I also didn’t have a reason to close them.

Even if some of my older accounts don’t get much use anymore, that doesn’t mean opening them was a mistake. They fulfilled their original purpose, and now their role is to help me preserve my credit history and available credit.

Unused Cards Can Still Be Useful

Every open credit card adds to my total available credit, which helps keep my credit utilization ratio low. For example, if I have $25,000 in combined limits and spend $7,500 on one card, my utilization is 30%. If I close a card with a $10,000 limit, my combined limits would fall to $15,000. At that point, the same $7,500 in spending would create a 50% utilization ratio, which is far above the level experts typically recommend.

My open but unused cards also support my long credit history. Those older accounts help offset the newer cards I open to earn welcome bonuses or better rewards.

It’s also helpful to have extra cards available when I need them. They can serve as backup in an emergency or for an unexpected expense, giving me more available credit if I need it.

Existing accounts can also come with occasional promotional offers. For example, I sometimes receive 0% APR balance transfer offers that could be useful if I need flexibility — and I wouldn’t have to apply for a new card to use one.

On one of my less-used cards, I added my teen as an authorized user. He uses it when he is out with friends, and I can track his purchases separately from mine.

Bottom Line: A no-annual-fee card doesn’t need to be especially rewarding to be worth keeping.

I Still Use Some of My Favorite No-Fee Cards Often

Although some cards, like my Capital One Platinum card, mostly serve my credit history, other no-annual-fee cards still provide ongoing value.

For example, I use my Freedom Unlimited card often because it works as an everyday spending card that earns Chase Ultimate Rewards without an annual fee. Its 3% cash back category covers dining and drugstore purchases, and its 1.5% cash back on everything else makes it a reliable catchall when I can’t earn more with another card.

Before I opened the Disney^® Inspire Visa^® Card, I used my $0-annual-fee Disney^® Visa^® Card to get cardholder perks at Walt Disney World, including discounts on merchandise and dining.

I also use cards that come with monthly credits, such as my Ink Business Unlimited^® Credit Card, which provides a $20 Instacart credit each month as long as I keep an Instacart+ membership. Those benefits run through December 31, 2027.

Downgrading Can Give a Premium Card a Second Life

Sometimes I want to stop paying an annual fee on a premium card without closing the account. When possible, I choose a product change to a no-annual-fee card so I can keep the account open while dropping the fee — the same approach I took when I downgraded my Chase Sapphire Reserve card to a Freedom Unlimited card.

That downgrade let me keep my account history, my credit limit, and my Chase Ultimate Rewards points, all without continuing to pay a premium annual fee. The only downside was that I did not qualify for a new-card welcome offer.

Hot Tip: Before closing an annual-fee card, ask the issuer whether you can downgrade to a no-annual-fee version and keep your account history and credit line.

Inactive Cards Still Require Attention

Card issuers may close inactive accounts, so I make small purchases on older cards to keep them active. I also log in regularly to review statements and watch for fraud, even when I expect the balance to be zero.

More open cards mean more accounts to keep track of, but that’s manageable with major issuers where I hold multiple cards, such as American Express, Chase, and Capital One.

I also use account tools to stay organized. I set alerts for transactions and due dates so I’m not caught off guard by activity on a card I rarely use.

Final Thoughts

Premium cards deliver some of the most valuable rewards and benefits in my wallet, but I review them every year to make sure they still justify their cost. It makes sense to close or downgrade premium cards when the value no longer outweighs the annual fee. My no-annual-fee cards don’t require that annual calculation because there is no fee to offset.

Every no-annual-fee card I keep serves some purpose, whether that is earning rewards, preserving my credit history, or providing extra available credit I can tap if needed. I may go years without using some of them for meaningful purchases, and that is perfectly fine.

Even though my premium cards are the most valuable in my wallet right now, my no-annual-fee cards are the ones I’m most confident I’ll still have years from now.