Two Matching Rolex Watches Can Be Treated Very Differently Under Medicaid Rules

Quick Read

• Medicaid can treat two identical Rolexes differently: a watch worn every day may be excluded from resource counts, while one kept as an inflation hedge may be counted.

• The federal SSI resource limit is $2,000, and a single investment-grade watch valued at its open-market resale price can push an applicant well over that amount.

• Giving either watch to a family member during Medicaid's 60-month look-back period can lead to penalties and delay nursing-home coverage.

A retired widow owns two identical stainless steel Rolex watches. She wears one to church, to the grocery store and to every grandchild's soccer game. The other remains in its original box inside a safe-deposit drawer. She bought that one as protection against inflation and never wore it. On the open market, the two watches would fetch the same price.

If she later applies for Medicaid nursing-home coverage, the watches could end up on different sides of the eligibility calculation. Under Supplemental Security Income-style resource rules, personal effects may be excluded, while property held mainly for its value or as an investment can be counted.

That distinction matters because many states apply SSI-style resource rules to older Medicaid applicants. For someone seeking nursing-home coverage, savings and other countable assets can affect eligibility, while personal items may be treated differently.

Rising prices can also complicate that picture. A retiree who views watches or jewelry as an inflation hedge may not realize that investment intent can matter later when Medicaid reviews assets.

Now Available: The 401k Answers Nobody Gives You.

For many Americans, saving in a 401(k) only creates more retirement questions. Should you roll the account into an IRA, and when? What happens if the rollover check is made out to the wrong name? When do required withdrawals begin, and how much must you take out?

“Personal Effects” Exclusion Has No Dollar Cap

Since a rule change took effect in 2005, Social Security has excluded qualifying household goods and personal effects no matter how much they are worth. Personal jewelry can qualify, including wedding and engagement rings. A watch worn regularly for personal use can fit that category regardless of price.

Jewelry kept for its value or as an investment does not receive the same protection, and the same can be true for gems, unworn jewelry and collectibles. Those items may count as resources unless another exclusion applies. In these cases, use and purpose matter more than the price tag alone.

Daily wear does not automatically protect a watch. In one Social Security example, a recipient spent part of an insurance settlement on jewelry she wore regularly. Because she bought it for its value as a way to spend down the settlement, the agency treated it as countable property.

Why the Boxed Watch Can Blow Through a $2,000 Limit

The federal SSI resource limit has stood at $2,000 for an individual and $3,000 for a couple since 1989. Many state Medicaid programs use that threshold for nursing-home applicants. A single investment-grade watch can push someone far beyond it.

A countable watch is generally valued at what it could reasonably sell for on the local open market. That can differ from a boutique price tag or the replacement value listed on an insurance policy. Families can support the value with dealer quotes, recent auction results or an appraisal based on resale value.

State rules vary. Some states use more generous methods than the SSI program, and asset limits and valuation practices differ from one Medicaid office to another. A watch that clears the test in one state may raise tougher questions in another.

Selling Either Watch Can Turn It Into Countable Cash

Under SSI rules, money from selling property is treated as a resource that has changed form. That can affect each watch differently.

Giving either watch to a grandson creates another issue. Medicaid penalizes assets that are gifted, transferred or sold for less than fair market value during its 60-month look-back period, which can delay coverage.

Paper Trails Decide Which Side a Watch Lands On

Caseworkers examine use, intent and value, so families that document all three usually have a stronger case. For a watch worn daily, that may mean dated photos of it on the owner's wrist, service records showing normal wear and family history such as an anniversary gift or a late husband's watch. For a piece bought as an investment, it means purchase receipts and a realistic resale appraisal so the family knows the countable amount before a caseworker determines it.

The widow's two identical Rolexes can still receive different treatment. The one she wears for personal use may be excluded, while the one she bought and keeps as an investment may count at its current market value.

Released: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers

(sponsor) 401(k)s are powerful retirement tools. But even experienced savers can make mistakes that quietly cost money for years. Choosing the wrong fund, overlooking small fees, or handling rollover steps in the wrong order can all cause problems.

Those are the kinds of mistakes 401k & IRA Tips and Answers was created to help prevent. It is a free guide from Fisher Investments covering rollovers, contributions, required withdrawals and the errors that can do the most damage to a retirement account. Learn More Here ›