The Roth IRA Error That Can Turn $6,150 a Month of Tax-Free Dividends Into a Tax Bill

Quick Read

• Roth withdrawals can become taxable and face a 10% penalty unless you are 59½ and at least five tax years have passed since your first Roth contribution.

• Each Roth conversion starts its own five-year penalty clock, so a newer conversion can trigger penalties even inside an account that has been open for decades.

• To produce $6,150 a month, you would need roughly $776,000 in a seven-holding portfolio with an estimated 10% yield, led by FSK and GPIX.

After years of building a Roth account, a retiree leaves work at 57 and begins taking $6,150 a month in dividends. In January, the custodian sends a Form 1099-R with code J in box 7.

That code indicates an early Roth distribution with no known exception. In effect, it puts $73,800 a year of income that was expected to be tax-free in front of the IRS.

How a Roth Withdrawal Becomes Taxable

A Roth payout is fully tax-free only if it qualifies as a qualified distribution. Two conditions must be met: you must be at least 59½, disabled, or the money must be paid to your heirs; and five tax years must have passed since the first year you contributed to any Roth IRA.

If either condition is not met, IRS ordering rules apply. Your regular contributions come out first, followed by conversions and then earnings (26 U.S.C. § 408A; IRS Pub. 590-B). Reinvested dividends are treated as earnings. Once withdrawals exceed your original contributions, the excess becomes taxable. If you are under 59½ and no exception applies, an additional 10% tax is also due.

Each conversion also has its own five-year clock for the penalty, which is why the years before required minimum distributions begin can be especially useful for planning. A recent conversion can trigger the penalty even in a Roth that was opened many years ago. Nonqualified withdrawals are reported on Form 8606.

------

Learn 7 Ways To Generate Income With A $1,000,000+ Portfolio

If you’ve saved over $1,000,000, this guide is for you. The last thing you want in retirement is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.

Now you can learn the strategies wealthy retirees use to fund their retirement with The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income from Fisher Investments. Download the guide today! (sponsor)

------

Three More Ways the Tax-Free Promise Can Break

• If you contribute more than allowed, the IRS imposes a 6% excise tax for each year the excess remains in the account. A recent fix-it guide explains how to clean it up.

• You can make only one IRA-to-IRA rollover in a 1-year period across all of your IRAs, including Roths. Trustee-to-trustee transfers do not count toward that limit.

• If you sell a fund at a loss in a taxable account and buy it in your Roth within 30 days, the IRS disallows the loss and does not add it to your cost basis, so you lose it permanently.

What $73,800 a Year Requires

Based on early November 2026 prices, the seven holdings below have a weighted yield of 9.5%. Divide $73,800 by that yield, and you need about $776,000.

Amplify CEF High Income ETF

Monthly distributions have declined from $0.20 in 2013 to $0.12. Its most recent filing lists no expense ratio, so investors should review the prospectus for total costs, including fees embedded in the funds it holds.

Goldman Sachs S&P 500 Premium Income ETF

Omega Healthcare Investors

Omega paid $0.67 per quarter from 2020 into early 2026, then increased it to $0.68. Third-quarter adjusted funds from operations reached $0.82 per share, leaving room to cover the dividend.

FS KKR Capital

FS KKR reduced its regular dividend this year. It paid $0.70 each quarter in 2025, then $0.48, $0.42, and $0.44 in 2026. Net asset value per share fell to $18.28 from $20.89.

British American Tobacco

PIMCO Corporate & Income Opportunity Fund

This fund often trades at a premium, which means buyers pay more than the value of the bonds it holds. If that premium narrows, investors can lose money even when the underlying bonds stay steady. Before buying, review the current premium and leverage.

Invesco Preferred ETF

Before Your First Withdrawal

This portfolio would need about $776,000 in a Roth to generate $6,150 a month. Withdrawals become fully tax-free on the later of your 59½ birthday or January 1 of the fifth tax year after your first contribution.

Before taking the first dollar, confirm the year of that first contribution and the date of every conversion with your custodian. Those records determine whether your 1099-R shows code Q, meaning qualified, or code J.

Learn 7 Ways To Generate Income With A $1,000,000+ Portfolio

If you’ve saved over $1,000,000, this guide is for you. The last thing you want in retirement is to run out of money, you want your money to generate lasting income while you enjoy your life.

Now you can learn the strategies wealthy retirees use to fund their retirement with The Definitive Guide to Retirement Income from Fisher Investments. Download the guide today! (sponsor)