Taking Social Security Back Pay After Full Retirement Age Can Permanently Shrink Your Monthly Check

Quick Read

• Accepting SSA back pay pushes your official filing date back six months, permanently eliminating delayed retirement credits worth 8% per year.

• A $12,480 lump sum reduces monthly payments by $80 for life, meaning it takes 13 years just to break even.

• The lump sum is treated as Social Security income, which can make up to 85% taxable and can also raise Medicare Part B premiums.

• The biggest 401(k) choices often get made once and never revisited: when to roll over an account, what to keep inside it, and when to start withdrawals. That is the focus of report: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers, which is free today. (Sponsor)

Imagine a retiree who reached full retirement age at 67 and waited until 68 to file for Social Security. During the application process, she is offered something that sounds like extra money: the Social Security Administration can pay six months of missed benefits in one lump sum.

She accepts the payment. What she may not realize is the trade-off. Taking the money shifts her official benefit start date back by six months, removes six months of delayed retirement credits, and lowers every future monthly check for the rest of her life.

Six Months of Back Pay Comes From Your Own Future Increases

The rule appears in the SSA's internal manual. For retirement claims filed after full retirement age, the agency allows retroactivity of up to six months, but never to a month before full retirement age. The agency says it cannot pay retroactive benefits for any month before that point or for more than six months in the past.

Back pay works by changing the entitlement date. If someone files at 68 and takes six retroactive months, the SSA treats the claim as if benefits started at 67 and a half. Any delayed retirement credits that would have been earned during those months are lost.

Now Available: The 401k Answers Nobody Gives You.

For many Americans, saving in a 401(k) only raises more retirement questions. Should the account be rolled into an IRA, and if so, when? What happens if the rollover check is made out incorrectly? When do required withdrawals begin, and how much must be taken?

For people born from 1943 onward, waiting past full retirement age adds 2/3 of 1% per month, or 8.0% per year, until the increase stops at age 70. Six months of back pay means giving up six of those monthly increases.

What the Rep Is Supposed to Tell You

The SSA manual instructs staff to explain the trade-off. Employees are told to make clear that taking the lump sum payment will permanently reduce the ongoing monthly benefit amount.

Worked Example: Trading $12,480 for $80 a Month

Assume a primary insurance amount of $2,000 a month, which is close to the average retired-worker benefit of $2,071. Cost-of-living adjustments are excluded to keep the math simple.

The lump sum delivers $12,480 up front. In return, the retiree gives up $80 a month, or $960 a year, for life. It would take 156 months, or about 13 years, for the smaller checks to offset the one-time payment. After that, the retiree is behind every month she lives.

Cost-of-living adjustments widen the gap, because each increase is based on a smaller monthly benefit. A 3.6% COLA would increase the $80 difference to about $82.88.

Married couples can lose even more. A surviving spouse may inherit the full delayed benefit of the deceased spouse, so a smaller benefit now can also mean a smaller survivor benefit later.

Tax Bill and Medicare Premiums Can Follow the Lump Sum

Back pay is treated as Social Security income in the year it is received. Once provisional income exceeds $34,000 for separate filers or $44,000 for joint filers, up to 85% of benefits can become taxable under federal law. At that level, about $10,608 of a $12,480 lump sum could end up in taxable income.

Medicare matters too. Part B premiums are based on income from two years earlier, and a higher-income surcharge begins above $109,000 for individuals and $218,000 for joint filers. Going over that line by even $1 raises the monthly premium from $202.90 to $284.10.

When Taking the Back Pay Still Makes Sense

If none of those trade-offs apply, the simplest option is to decline the back pay and begin benefits in the month you apply. Before signing, ask the representative for two figures: your monthly benefit with the retroactive start date and your monthly benefit without it. Because the choice cannot be undone later, it is wise to have a fiduciary advisor or CPA review the numbers first.

Released: 401k & IRA Tips and Answers

(sponsor) 401(k)s are powerful retirement tools, but even careful savers can make mistakes that cost money for decades. Choosing the wrong fund, overlooking small fees, or handling rollovers in the wrong order can all be expensive errors.

These are the kinds of mistakes 401k & IRA Tips and Answers was created to help prevent. It is a free guide from Fisher Investments covering rollovers, contributions, required withdrawals, and common account mistakes. Learn More Here ›